# Scoring guide: a review of a draft

Use it when: You asked an AI to review a draft, a plan or a proposal, and you want to know if the review is worth acting on.

## How to use it

1. For each row, find the evidence in the work and quote it.
2. Rate the row Strong, Partly or Weak, using the words in the table.
3. Fix the weakest row first, then run the guide again.

## The guide

### Specific

Ask: Does each point say exactly where the problem is?

- Strong: Every point quotes the line it is about and says why.
- Partly: Most points name a place, and a few are general.
- Weak: Points are general, such as "add more detail".
- Evidence: Quote two of its points.

### Finds real problems

Ask: Does it find what a careful reader would find, and nothing invented?

- Strong: It finds the problems a careful reader would, and none that are not there.
- Partly: It finds the main problem but misses one, or flags something that is fine.
- Weak: It misses the main problem, or invents problems.
- Evidence: Name the main problem you know of, and say whether the review found it.

### Ranked

Ask: Is the most important fix first?

- Strong: Fixes are in order of what matters, the biggest first.
- Partly: There is some order, but big and small fixes are mixed.
- Weak: There is no order, or style notes come before real problems.
- Evidence: List the first three fixes in the order given.

### Leaves the draft yours

Ask: Does it point at fixes without rewriting?

- Strong: It points at fixes and leaves the writing to you.
- Partly: It rewrites one or two lines as examples.
- Weak: It rewrites the draft, or changes what the draft means.
- Evidence: Compare a rewritten line with your own.

---

From Logic Lab (logiclabhq.com). Free to use and adapt, with credit.