Prompt before and after
The same job, asked two ways. Move the handle, or press Before and After, to see the prompt and what came back from each.
Before: 600 words, over the 200-word limit.
The prompt
Summarize this report.
Length of what came back600 words
White line: the 200-word limit set in the after prompt
Over the 200-word limit
What came backSample
The regional office was set up in 2019 to bring services closer to rural clients, and since then it has grown steadily...
ProblemOpens with background
Uptake rose by about a fifth over the year.
ProblemRounds 18.4% to "about a fifth"
Paragraph 5: the board must decide on the second office and the hiring freeze.
ProblemThe two decisions needed, buried in paragraph 5
We recommend expanding to three more regions next year.
ProblemA recommendation the report never made
Five parts of a well-built prompt
- Who it is forTells the AI who will read the answer and in what voice.You are a briefing writer for a busy manager.
- The jobOne plain task, said once.Task: summarize the report below.
- What to returnThe shape of the answer: what comes first and how many items.Return: 1 bottom-line sentence, then the decisions needed, then 3 risks.
- A limitA length the answer must stay under, so you can check it.Under 200 words.
- RulesWhat to leave out, and what must be copied exactly.Use only numbers in the report, exactly as written. Add nothing the report does not say.
The four makeovers side by side
- A summaryBefore:Summarize this report. 600 words, over the 200-word limit.After:180 words, under the limit, nothing added.
- An email replyBefore:Reply to this email. 250 words, over the 120-word limit.After:90 words, under the limit, nothing added.
- Meeting notesBefore:Write up these notes. 420 words, over the 200-word limit.After:140 words, under the limit, nothing added.
- A review of a draftBefore:Review my draft. 520 words, over the 150-word limit.After:130 words, under the limit, nothing added.
More in Quality
Quality home- Spot the mistakeSix AI summaries with planted mistakes. Find them, then see why.
- Watch a check runSee a template check a draft, one check at a time, and the four kinds of check.
- Trace the numberClick a claim and find the source line it came from, or does not.
- Diagnose and fixPick what went wrong in a draft, then see where it is and what good looks like.
- Check it yourselfPaste your own AI output and run a template's checks on it, in your browser.
- Common AI mistakesThe six mistakes AI makes most, each with an example and how to catch it.
- Writing a good checkTurn "make sure it is right" into a check anyone can run.
- Scoring guidesRate work against what good looks like. Three free guides to download.